Books Catalogue
Books Catalogue

Informal Sector and its Role in Arab Countries

 

Author: Ahmed Al-Kawaz
Series:
Price: $20.00 (KD6.000)
ISBN Number:
Language: English
Publisher: Arab Planning Institute - Kuwait
Description:

The papers in this volume attempt to survey definitions of informal activities with reference to those Arab countries that deal with informal activities using the Egyptian census of establishments. The features of informal finance are studied with references to Egypt and Sudan, and by tackling the institutional aspects of informal activities.

The first paper, by Nedelec and Destremau, discusses the concept and definition of informal activities. They believe that interest in the concept of informality began in 1971 with Hart in his study on Informal Income Opportunities and Urban Employment in Ghana. The term informal was used to refer to those workers who were surplus to the requirement of wage labour in African cities (Hart, 1973). Since then, the heterogeneity of the concept has been the main characteristic of informal activities, which includes illegal, underground and moonlighting activities. Having surveyed the main definitions of informality from such institutions as the ILO, Economic Research Forum (ERF), the Moroccan Statistical Office, and the Conference of Labour Statisticians, the paper moves on to provide some Arab examples of definitions of informality. Egypt, for instance, emphasises on size criterion in terms of employed workers. Another example is provided by Algeria where, contrary to the situation in Egypt, there is no consensus on the criterion used. The criteria used there vary from the size of activities and the existence of a parallel currency exchange market, to the existence of a black market for goods and services. If there is any common factor among the definitions of informal activities in Algeria, it is that all operate outside the state control.

This first paper recommends, among other things, the need for full cooperation between Arab national statistical offices and international community in implementing the recommendations of the International Conference of Statisticians regarding a common definition of informal activities.

The second paper, by Fergany, addresses the relations between informal activities and structural adjustment, again with application to the Egyptian case. The paper starts by refuting the single-criterion definition approach to informality, and selects instead five characteristics with which to distinguish informal activities, namely, the number of establishments, employment, failure rate, workers earnings, and value-added. Special attention is paid to the first three characteristics.

Using statistical evidence derived from Labour Force Sample Survey (LFSS) and census of establishments, the paper tests the ability of the public sector and informal activities to absorb any more employmees because of the implementation of adjustment policies and the effect of such policies on informal activities. The paperâ??s findings indicate that the public sector will not be able to accommodate all the surplus employment resulting from the adjustment policies, whereas the informal activities are qualified to absorb more employment but at a slower pace and with lower productivity. Responding to the second question, the effect of adjustment policies on informal activities, the paper indicates that the effect is negative. The evidence is provided by the decline in the number of self-employed and other small-scale establishments during the last three decades coupled with an increase in the number of large establishments.

The third paper, by Al-Kawaz, relates to informal finance. Due to the severe lack of information, reference is made to only two Arab countries: Egypt and Sudan. The paper starts with a discussion of informality and informal finance as they relate to the financial markets in those two countries.. Then a survey of the different types of informal finance, e.g., rotating saving and credit associations (ROSCAs), moneylenders, pawnbrokers, and community groups, is provided.

Later, the paper focuses on the Egyptian experience with ROSCAs in terms of borrower groups, the average life span of ROSCAs, the number of required rotations, the average kitty size, the leaders reasons for initiating ROSCAs, default problems, etc. The Egyptian case shows that no rate of interest is involved due to the nature of ROSCAs, the alternative sources of formal finance in operation, and the fact that a few members of ROSCAs are engaged in other types of informal finance, such as trade credit.

The Sudanese case, on the other hand, shows the sheil system prevailing in the rural areas. This system is alleged to be a legal substitute for usury. Informal finance, according to the sheil system, depends on the locationâ??s distance from the source of water, the farmerâ??s indebtedness, and reputation of the tenant. On contrary to ROSCAs, the sheil system burdens farmers with a heavy rate of interest, which represents the difference between the lenderâ??s selling price at market and the price paid to the borrower before harvest.

In order to formalise informal finance, the paper suggests the need to encourage micro-finance institutions in Arab countries, in such a way to reduce the borrowing cost, especially in rural areas, and to maximise the number of people who are eligible for credit in the hope of reducing poverty in the medium and long run. In this respect, two cases on micro-finance are provided, i.e., Grameen Bank in Bangladesh, and Alexandria Business Association in Egypt.

After discussing how informal finance is influenced by a financial liberalisation policy, the consequences of financial repression and liberalisation on informal financial markets is explored. The interdependence between informal and formal financial markets under a policy of liberalisation is also investigated.

The fourth and last paper, by Mansour, studies the institutional framework of informal activities in a number of Arab countries. This aspect is tackled through Arab macroeconomic policies, state regulations, and role of government organizations and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) in promoting informal activities.

Macroeconomic policies in most Arab countries are biased against informal and small-scale industries and in favour of large-scale ones. Many examples of investment cases are provided, such as Syria, Jordan, Egypt, Qatar, and the United Arab Emirates. For instance, in Jordan, projects are entitled to benefit from the exemptions and incentives of investment law if their capital exceeds a certain amount, which is beyond all informal activities. The same is true in other Arab countries as well.

State regulations are seen in terms of labour, and tax regulations, licensing, and registration. In case of Oman, for example, the state empowered the Ministry of Social Affairs and Labour to fix minimum wages. In Maghreb countries and Egypt, workers enjoy more protection than in other Arab countries. They have stronger labour union, fixed wage laws, protection from firing, and reasonable social benefits.

Generally speaking, incomes generated from agriculture, poultry, cattle, etc., are exempted from income tax in most Arab countries. Despite the difficulty of distinguishing between formal and informal activities, Arab countries do exempt capital and income which does not exceed a certain amount from taxes. As for licensing, Arab countries have attempted to demolish this type of barrier, since it is part and parcel of the economic liberalisation policies followed by most of them. Registration of new projects, however, is required in most Arab countries. Only few, as Oman, and Saudi Arabia, exempt small-scale industries and handicrafts from registration.

This paper creates a picture of the role of governmental organisations and NGOs in the informal sector. With the support of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), most Arab Ministries of Social Affairs have initiated poverty-combating programmes which include the promotion of small-scale industries and informal activities. The Social Fund for Development in Egypt, Noor Al Hussein Foundation and Queen Alia Fund in Jordan, are good examples of such efforts.



 

Table of contents

PREFACE ix

LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS x

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1
Ahmed Al-Kawaz

CHAPTER 2 NOTES ON THE DEVELOPMENTS OF THE CONCEPT 5
AND DEFINITION OF INFORMAL ECONOMY
Serge Nedelec and Blandine Destremau
INTRODUCTION 5
1. THE BIRTH OF THE CONCEPT, THE FIRST APPROACHES, 5
AND DEFINITION OF INFORMAL ECONOMY
1.1 The Birth of the Concept 5
1.2 The Initial Double Approach to the Informal Economy 7
1.3 The Various Typologies of the Informal Sector 8
1.4 The Expansion of an â??Analytical Weak Conceptâ?‌ 9

2. SUCCESSIVE DEFINITIONS AND A CRITICAL SURVEY OF 10
SOME MAIN CHARACTERISTICS
2.1 The Various Definitions of Informal Economy 10
2.1.1 The First Multi-Criteria Definitions 10
2.1.2 To Each His Own Definition 10
2.1.3 The Recent Efforts of the ILO towards a 11
Standard Definition of Informal Activities
2.2 A Critical View of Some Features of the Informal Economy 30
2.2.1 The Criterion of Size 12
2.2.2 The Case of Egypt 13
2.2.3 The Criterion of Non-Respect for the Law 14
2.4 The Case of the Informal Economy in Algeria 15
2.5 The Problem of Accounting for Pluri-Activity 16

3. THE DEVELOPMENT OF PERCEPTIONS AND POLICIES 17
REGARDING INFORMAL ACTIVITIES
3.1 A Political Slogan of the 1970s-1980s: â??Formalise 18
the Informalâ?‌
3.2 The Change of Perspective on the Informal Sector: 18
The Lure of Liberalism
3.3 The Informal Economy and the Struggle Against Poverty 20
3.4 The New Political Nature of Informal Activities 21
3.5 The Supposed Advantages of the Informal Economy 21
4. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS 22
NOTES 24
REFERENCES 24

CHAPTER 3 INFORMAL ECONOMIC ACTIVITY AND STRUCTURAL 28
ADJUSTMENT IN ARAB COUNTRIES: APPLICATION TO THE
CASE OF EGYPT
Nader Fergany
INTRODUCTION 28
1. THE INFORMATION PREDICAMENT 29
1.1 The Fallacy of the One-Criterion Formal-Informal Duality 30
1.2 Informality is Important in Arab Countries 32
2. STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT AND INFORMAL-SMALL 32
ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
3. THE INFORMAL- ECONOMY: A WAT OUT OF THE WOES 41
OF STRUCTURAL ADJUSTMENT
APPENDIX 1: Information Base for Small and Micro-Enterprise 44
Development
APPENDIX 2: Estimation of Establishment Failure Rates from 44
the Census of Establishments Data, Egypt
REFERENCES 45

CHAPTER 4 INFORMAL FINANCE WITH SOME REFERENCE TO THE EGYPTIAN 47
AND SUDANESE CASES
Ahmed Al-Kawaz
INTRODUCTION 47
1. INFORMAL SECTOR-DEFINITIONS 47
1.1 Informal Finance 48
1.2 Types of Informal Finance 49
2. INFORMAL FINANCE: THE EGYPTIAN AND SUDANESE 51
EXPERIENCES
2.1 Credit Delivery Systems 51
2.2 Rate of Interest 53
3. MICROFINANCING INFORMAL FINANCE 53
3.1 The Grameen Bankâ??s Experience 54
3.1.1 The Financial Mechanism 55
3.1.2 Evaluation 55
3.1.3 Arab Microfinance 57


4. FINANCAL REPRESSION AND LIBERALISATION 58
5. INFORMAL FINANCE AND FINANCIAL LIBERALISATION 59
6. Some Policy Options 60
NOTES 61
REFERENCES 62

CHAPTER 5 INSTITUTIONAL STRUCTURES AND THE (PRIVATE) 65
INFORMAL SECTOR IN ARAB COUNTRIES
Antoine Mansour
INTRODUCTION 65
1. THE CONCEPT OF INFORMAL SECOR OR INFORMAL ECONOMY? 66
2. INFORMAL ECONOMY AND THE ROLE OF THE STATE 67
2.1 The Procession of Formalisation and Informalisation 67
in Arab Countries
2.2 Macroeconomic Policies Based in Favour of the 68
2.3 Reaction of Firms to Macroeconomic Policies and the 69
State Regulation of the Economy
3. IMPACT OF LABOUR, TAX AND STANDARDS REGULATIONS 70
ON THE INFORMAL ECONOMY
3.1 Labour Regulations 70
3.2 Standards and Norms 74
4. IMPACT OF LICENSING AND REGISTRATION ON THE 75
INFORMAL ECONOMY
4.1 Licensing 75
4.2 Registration 76
5. ROLE OF GOVERNMENT ORGANISATIONS AND NGOs IN THE 76
PROMOTION OF INFORMAL MICRO- AND SMALL ACTIVITIES
6. CONCLUSION 78
NOTES 79

REFERENCES 80


 

Date: 1999

 

Number of Pages: 82

 

Price : $20.00 (KD6.000)

 

 


Other Issues of Book Catalogue


Payment Method